Saturday, February 19, 2011

AT&T says turning cell tower visible from St. Croix River into art is too expensive

Company nixes idea to hide tower in sculpture park

By Karl Bremer

Once in a blue moon, a brilliant solution to a prickly problem comes around that is so serendipitous you have to wonder how anyone could be opposed to it.

Until you find out that this brilliant solution stands in the way of corporate profits.

Take the situation up in Chisago County, where AT&T has proposed planting a 150-foot cell-phone tower just a mile from the St. Croix River, and literally at the gateway to the St. Croix National Scenic Riverway. According to a report by Mary Divine in the St. Paul Pioneer Press, computer models show the tower could be visible on the river up to 3 miles downstream.

Nevertheless, despite the protestations of the St. Croix River Association and Chris Stein, local riverway superintendent for the National Park Service, the tower received the blessing of the Franconia Township Board of Supervisors, the Chisago County Planning Commission and the Chisago County Board of Commissioners, who signed off on it by a 3-2 vote in January. Commissioners Lora Walker and Ben Montzka voted no.

The proposed site for the tower is near the intersection of Minnesota Highway 95 and U.S. Highway 8—directly across 95 from the Franconia Sculpture Park. John Hock, the park’s CEO and artistic director, doesn’t want to look at the tower from the entrance to the wildly eclectic sculpture park, so he has proposed inviting the tower in to become part of the sculpture park.

“If we put it in the sculpture garden, we’d have a national call for a sculpture to hide a 150-ft tall cell phone tower,” Hock muses. “You would have a national competition, which we do with our fellowships anyway. Have a call for qualifications or letters of interest, and then you have a competition. A committee that could include AT&T and community people could winnow it down to three to five artists and then you could select one.”

Hock says the sculpture garden issues about 75 grants a year. This award could be written so that a technically feasible sculpture could be built that would serve AT&T’s needs without compromising its service.

A walk around the Franconia Sculpture Park confirms that this would, indeed, be an ideal location for a cell tower disguised as art. Brightly colored hulking metal pieces dot the landscape, along with a shed suspended in the air like something out of the Wizard of Oz, alien-like orbs spinning in the air, and a whimsical purple medicine show wagon wherein, a sign promises, “great secrets of nature appear.”

One can only wonder what a collective of metal sculpture artists could come up with that would satisfy riverway enthusiasts, the local community and AT&T.

“We’re delighted to get these ideas from the community,” insists AT&T spokesperson Tom Hopkins, “but in this case it’s a little expensive and could be technically impractical … There are a lot of unknowns when you’re talking about a sculpture. It’s a science, and we know exactly how to do that in a way that’s technically viable. We’ve had a lot of experience camouflaging these towers in a way that makes them invisible to most people.”

What it really comes down to, though, is cost.

The idea of hiding a cell tower in a sculpture “is a one-off,” says Hopkins. “It’s really outside the norm,” noting again that it would be “a little expensive.”

AT&T posted over $1 billion profit in the fourth quarter of 2010. AT&T reported a net gain of 2.8 million mobile customers during that same period, the largest quarterly gain in the company's history. Mobile service revenue increased 9.6 percent, to $13.8 billion, over the fourth quarter of 2010.

Dan Willius, chair of the St. Croix River Association, isn’t swayed by AT&T’s assurances that the tower won’t be visible.

Willius told the Pioneer Press: “People say, ‘Well, it’s just one cell tower,’ but each one of these things adds up. It’s what I refer to as death by a thousand cuts.”

Willius says his group’s attorneys are reviewing their options. Stein says he is discussing the matter with national officials. Sometimes the threat of legal action is what it takes for a corporation like AT&T to have its own “Can you hear me now?” moment.

That’s what it took up north near Ely, where the Friends of the Boundary Waters Wilderness sued last year to halt construction of a 450-foot AT&T tower proposed for a ridge 1.5 miles from the Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness. The group alleges the tower, which will rise 600 feet above the landscape, will be visible from several lakes within the BWCAW and violates the Minnesota Environmental Rights Act, and has asked AT&T to consider less intrusive solutions to their cell tower needs there.

At a hearing last August on a temporary injunction to halt the tower’s construction, AT&T agreed to suspend construction of the tower until a trial is held on the merits of the group’s lawsuit. A trial date is pending.

AT&T’s Hopkins insists that “it’s all about working with the community,” but it doesn’t appear the multibillion-dollar corporation tried very hard in Franconia Township. It may have gotten the imprimatur of local officials, but it neglected to consider the national treasure its tower threatens to despoil, even if it’s just one of a thousand cuts. NPS Superintendent Stein didn’t even hear about the proposed tower until just a few days before the county board voted on it.

It shouldn’t take lawyers to get AT&T to behave like a good corporate citizen in Franconia Township, especially when a novel and creative solution such as a sculpture competition exists. But if that’s what required, then perhaps the St. Croix River Association and NPS should be talking to the Friends of the Boundary Waters Wilderness, if they aren’t already.

Maybe AT&T will hear them then.

All photos from the Franconia Sculpture Park by Karl Bremer.


  1. Art for Arts sake
    Money for God's sake
    Great read Karl.
    But come on. Without more cell towers how will those IPhone users stay connected in 4G?

  2. I completely agree with this. Thanks! The cell tower development service is incredibly increasing by uplifting the weaker sections of the country. With the help of cell tower development service, people are interlinked with each other in the country by enhancing global connectivity of the economy. Now days, there are numerous companies that are providing the service of cell tower development services. One such leading development company, named as, Parallel Infrastructure provides right of way services, which is significantly expanding its operations in the field of telecommunication infrastructure, energy infrastructure etc.

  3. Your work is great and I welcome you and jumping for some more enlightening posts. Much obliged to you for sharing extraordinary data to us.

  4. With each passing day, you come to know about a new mobile phone. Not a wonder, as number of mobile phone users is increasing in the same proportion imeitrackeronline

  5. very good article and useful once for my admin and pardon me permission to share articles herein may be useful and helpful Cara menyembuhkan flu tulang

  6. may be useful for all, helpful article once and pardon me permission to share also here

    Obat kejang kejang
    Obat keloid
    Obat lambung bengkak

  7. Now you can all connect through the Internet. Free SMS is the way that has come forth as a medium whereby you can send the free SMS through different mobile phone

  8. thank you've made an excellent website and this interesting. I am so inspired by your website. Its contents are highly qualified
    obat stroke
    obat jantung bengkak
    obat radang lambung
    obat batuk berdarah

  9. I read your complete survey. It's really great & amazing presentation. Thanks a lot for providing this marvelous information which i need so much
    obat fistula ani
    obat batuk berdarah
    obat benjolan di kepala
    obat infeksi saluran kencing
    obat kelenjar getah bening

  10. The information you provided is very true. I agree with your thoughts and appreciate your hard-work to write this beautiful post.
    obat gonore
    obat polip hidung
    cara menyembuhkan paru paru basah
    obat ambeien
    obat kelenjar getah bening

  11. News that you serve a very nice and interesting to see, hopefully this news can be useful for everything. success
    Terapi Penyembuhan Herbal
    Obat Infeksi Saluran Kencing

  12. Website you manage very neat and not boring. I was really amazed by you. The contents of the article is very original. thanks for the work, may be a inpirasi for everything.
    obat infeksi saluran kencing
    obat radang paru paru
    obat ginjal bocor
    obat pengapuran tulang

  13. This looks SO good! My mother-in-law makes something that looks/sounds just like this, and it is my favorite dessert she makes.
    obat jantung bengkak
    obat infeksi saluran kencing
    obat ginjal bocor
    obat paru paru basah

  14. I was very impressed with you. website you create highly qualified and highly original contents.
    obat batu ginjal
    cara menghilangkan dan membersihkan darah kotor

  15. I would never crave to lose out any chance to look throughout your contents.
    hero tameer

  16. Regarding all aspects the blog was perfectly nice.
    mall in hyderabad

  17. This post is quite informative for blogging and we all need to rethink about this issue
    ||Play happy wheels Are you ready||Now Free Happywheels
    ||Fireboy and watergirl game 4 online at||
    ||total Jerkface happy wheels game||

  18. I think there are many artists who want to do it. Expensive or not, they could earn money from it later.
    instagram viewer

  19. I think this is a really good article. You make this information interesting and engaging. You give readers a lot to think about and I appreciate that kind of writing. bitcoin

  20. This information is very useful. Thank you for sharing. and I will also share information about health through on our site please visit.